Mr. Pizza Slice Reviews

Mr. Pizza Slice has an overall rating of 3.7 based on 14 reviews. Customer feedback on Mr. Pizza Slice is mixed.

3.7/5.0

14 reviews

5 Stars

5

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

6

2 Stars

0

1 Star

1

All Mr. Pizza Slice Reviews (14)
robert-Goehner
May 18, 2026
"Promo Code Didn’t Apply at Checkout"
I tried using the special offer code and it seemed like it should work, but when I got to checkout, the total still showed the full price. I went back and double-checked everything, but nothing changed. Frustrating, honestly. In my opinion, if a code is being promoted, it should apply without this much hassle.
CarrollKimpton
May 16, 2026
"Delivery was a little slow"
The pizza took a while to get here, a bit longer than I expected. It was late, but it was still warm enough when it arrived, so it wasn’t a huge deal.
hello_justin775
May 05, 2026
"I’ll admit, I usually stick with my go-to..."
I’ll admit, I usually stick with my go-to pizza place, so I wasn’t sure I’d be swayed. But just looking through the menu, there was a really good mix of pizzas, sides, and other bits that made it feel easy to find something for everyone. It didn’t have that same-old, same-old feeling, which definitely made me pause and think I might have to branch out more often...
Ida_vaughn91
April 23, 2026
"Really nice customer service"
I had a little mix-up with my order , so I reached out to mrpizzaslice.com and expected it to be a bit of a hassle . They got back to me quickly though , and were really easygoing about it .

They sorted everything out without making me feel awkward or like I was bothering them . It was simple , polite customer service , but it definitely left a good impression and I’d order from them again
eugene-Jarrell
April 14, 2026
"Pretty easy, no hassle"
I ordered a pizza through the site and it was... simple. Payment went through without any issues, and my order was ready when I showed up. No complaints.
suzanne-Linehan
April 09, 2026
"Pretty clean overall"
I stopped in for a couple slices the place was clean. The tables were wiped down, the floor looked fine, and the counter area wasn’t cluttered or gross, which I always appreciate. I mean, it’s just basic decency to keep a place where people eat in decent shape, and they mostly did that. The bathroom could use a little more attention, but overall I felt comfortable eating there. 4 stars
Lulu_wiggins95
March 30, 2026
"Mostly Right, But Not Quite"
I ordered from mrpizzaslice.com and most of the order was fine, but my pizza was missing one of the toppings I picked, and we ended up getting regular crust instead of thin crust.

The food still tasted okay, and delivery wasn’t late, so it wasn’t a total bad experience. It’s just kind of frustrating when you choose specific options and they don’t get them right. Not awful, just average.
KyleHooker_62
March 06, 2026
"Big slices, easy win"
I ordered from mrpizzaslice.com and right away noticed the slices were bigger than I expected. I usually kind of judge pizza places by whether one slice is actually enough or if I end up needing two, and this one passed that test. One slice filled me up well, so no complaints from me. Solid value if you're hungry.
Amanda_golden96
February 24, 2026
"I really liked the crust"
I’m picky about pizza crust, but I thought this one was really good. It was thin and crispy without being too chewy, which is exactly how I like it. I loved it.
JohnFrisbie_34
February 21, 2026
"Good pizza, would definitely get it again"
The pizza was really tasty overall. The cheese was good, the crust wasn’t all dry or anything, and the sauce had a nice flavor to it. I’d order it again for sure, I just wish it had shown up a little hotter
Robert_tedder93
January 24, 2026
"The pizza tasted fine, but it showed..."
The pizza tasted fine, but it showed up barely warm, which was disappointing. I ended up having to reheat it myself, and for what delivery costs these days, I’d really expect it to arrive hot. Not terrible, just a bit annoying.
raquel_Santiago82
January 23, 2026
"Decent slice, but overpriced"
The slice tasted fine, nothing amazing but definitely okay. I just don’t think it’s worth paying full price for. Also, I asked a couple questions and kept getting different answers, which was kind of annoying. Overall, it’s alright if you’re really craving it, but I wouldn’t go out of my way
hello_reanna290
December 16, 2025
"Toppings felt a little hit or miss"
I ordered a pizza from Mr Pizza Slice it was just okay. The crust was decent enough, but the toppings felt kind of uneven, like they weren’t all coming from the same level of freshness.

The onions and peppers tasted good, but the mushrooms seemed a little old and the tomatoes were watery. I couldn’t help wondering if they were trying to use up some older toppings rather than tossing them, because it had that kind of vibe.

It wasn’t bad enough to make me write them off completely, but it definitely wasn’t great either. I might give them another try sometime, but I’d really hope the toppings are fresher and more consistent next time.
chris_Houser04
December 07, 2025
"the box showed up a bit bent..."
the box showed up a bit bent, but the pizza itself was totally fine.
Have a question about Mr. Pizza Slice?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.